Carnet de Villard de Honnecourt. d’après le manuscrit conservé à la Bibliothèque nationale de Paris, n ° Description matérielle: p. dont 66 p. de pl. In the footsteps of Villard de Honnecourt Villard de Honnecourt, a 13th century draughtsman, whose carnet or portfolio is still in existence. Review of Alain Erlande-Brandenburg et alia, Carnet de Villard de Honnecourt, in Archives Internationales d’Histoire des Sciences, vol.
|Published (Last):||14 May 2010|
|PDF File Size:||1.73 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||19.8 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
We thank them all, most especially Robert G. He was very much occupied with the question of his afterlife and that of his oeuvre, bringing this together in big manuscripts presenting his magnum opus C abruptly and inexplicably ended his pagination effort on fol.
To protect the leaves on the inside of the spine, a modern cloth lining had been attached. Quire II followed Quire I and is linked to it by the 13th-century lettering scheme, a q on fol. Finally, sometime after the pagination by C but before Mancel’s 15th-century pagination, C’s fol. In this sense I see that there is an important job of work for the artist who is concerned with old art and music to set against that of the exegetes or academics: We know nothing whatsoever.
Quire II ends on fol. One commentator has proposed that these leaves were originally some 1.
Tempo, phrasing and ornamentation are of course very strongly dependant on the acoustics of a church. This image may not be in the public domain in these countries, which moreover do not implement the rule of the shorter term. Using honnrcourt ink and writing in a hurried and rather crude hand, this anonymous paginator, whom we call C, lettered fols.
File:Villard de Honnecourt.djvu
Barnes, Junior, Lon R. Here he settled for two single leaves. These numbers are lower on ce leaves and came later because in at least three instances fols. Quire VII has lost more leaves than any other quire in the portfolio. Nowhere is this more evident than on Ossuairesthe first of three ambitious recordings created around the travels and shadowy biography of a certain Villard de Honnecourt, a 13th century draughtsman, whose carnet or portfolio is still in existence.
Carl F. Barnes, Jr. Publications on Villard de Honnecourt
For a summary history of the Villard portfolio and of the bibliography concerning it from tosee Carl F. Shelby has also demonstrated that the conclusion reached by Paul Frankl, based on Hahnloser’s Bauhiittenbuch thesis, that the Villard portfolio was a Lehrbuch, a textbook used to instruct medieval masons, is untenable 6. This incompleteness is most unfortunate, because several leaves were lost between the time of this 13th-century pagination and villsrd done in the 15th century.
I have no idea how I serve them! The Chartres Cathedral west facade rose on fol. There is post facto evidence for the arrangement of the leaves in vlllard 15th-century Uonnecourt pagination scheme and in the 18th century the numbering schemes of C The second inscription will be analyzed below, when discussing Quire VII.
On this level, the territory, the body of the saint is defining the complex of social, religious and economical activities. He ee not comment on how Villard protected his drawings before they were stitched into their cover. What Villard had were individual sheets of parchment on se he made drawings of diverse subjects at different times The catapult drawing was on the verso of the missing leaf, where it faced Villard’s catapult plan and inscription on fol.
This location for bifolio is likewise confirmed by a Master III inscription that begins on fol. First, the codicological evidence does not support Hahnloser’s hypothesis that approximately half of the original leaves of the portfolio honnecorut been lost.
But of course, it started with something very simple: What do you believe is being created from this combination of music from the Ars subtilior and dance?
If they discover that all this is also complex, multilayered, virtuosic, and so on, than all the better! However, the tab of fol.
Villard de Honnecourt – Wikipedia
It is certain that Villard took these first steps to transform his portfolio into a bound livre. Quire III ends abruptly on fol. What I am wanting to say here is that the images of Villard de Honnecourt are also surrounded by all sorts of crazy explanations which destroy the experience we could have with them.
The generally poor condition of these leaves is accounted for in some instances by the fact that Villard used inexpensive, low-grade parchment n ; in other instances leaves have been scraped to form which roughened and weakened these leaves Through thinking in this way the link between the territory, the soil as territory of the ancestors, and the operations of memory suddenly becomes clear.
Elizabeth of Hungary who had made a donation to the cathedral chapter and to whom the chapter dedicated one of the radiating chapels in their new chevet. The Industrial Revolution of the Middle Ages. Villard de Honnecourt did not provide any pagination for the leaves of his portfolio, but later users did so in the 13th, 15th, and 18th centuries. One must build any interpretation of Villard’s intention on the basis of what is currently in the portfolio, not on hypothetical of a document that would have been nearly double its extant size and different from the present ordering of the quires and the leaves within these quires.
Clearly a leaf which he numbered xi is missing and this leaf originally was integrally connected with fol. This is definitely not about the question of whether ornaments were added or not, or if this or that ornament was appropriate to the style. This speculative aspect of his work is to be as greatly regretted as his methodical analyses are to be praised, for his publication established, first in the scholarly literature of medieval art history, then through misinformation transmitted to several generations of students, two fundamental errors concerning the Villard drawings.
Beyond this, nothing whatsoever is known of the composition or content of Quire VII in Mancel’s time or earlier, and it is thus futile to speculate on either