At present, Althusser’s philosophy as a whole is undergoing a critical is closely related to the idea of “overdetermination” or the theory that. Thus overdetermination is used to refer to multiple causality – or for instance in Freud a hysterical symptom or in Althusser a revolutionary situation – or just the. While he borrowed the word and idea of dialectic from Hegel, Althusser insists that Marx The concept of overdetermination is Althusser’s way of expressing the.
|Country:||Central African Republic|
|Published (Last):||23 July 2014|
|PDF File Size:||1.20 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||13.33 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
That Althusser regards most, if not all, human activity as consisting of material processes of production and reproduction can be used as a key to understanding other parts of his philosophy. Email required Address never made public. Marx describes a number of the capitalist mode of production as tendencies notably the tendency of the rate of profit to fall.
The Hegelian totality is the essence behind the multitude of its phenomena, but the Marxist totality is a decentred structure in dominance.
Notify me of new comments via email. Ben Brewster and David Fernbach Verso: We could therefore take over the dialectic from him and apply it to althussser rather than to the Idea. The concentration of industrial monopolies, their subordination to financial monopolies, had increased the exploitation of the workers and of the colonies. We must admit that this extraction cannot be painless; in appearance an unpeeling, it is really a demystificationan operation which transforms what it extracts.
These new conditions involve the specific type of relations between the agents of production which exist as a function of the relations between these agents on the one hand and the material means of production are on no account reducible to mere relations between men, to relations which only involve men, and therefore to variations in a universal matrix, to inter-subjectivity recognition, prestige, struggle, master-slave relationship, etc.
For Marx, it describes the fact that capitalism, having come into being by the destruction of feudalism, is itself destined to be destroyed by the rise of socialism and communism [this description makes a metaphorical use of the notion.
A market voerdetermination a particular section of Sofia, Bulgaria in would have a different logic of interactions and outcomes than a market in a particular section of Tokyo, Japan in the same year, and a different logic of interactions and outcomes than a market in that same section of Sofia in the year or a market created in Sofia through linking servers that process electronic data on bids and asks taken over the Internet.
Presses Universitaires de France. For Althusser, it is not necessary that this process of distinction and clarification be accomplished before a specific theoretical practice can generate scientific knowledge.
Sorry, your browser doesn’t support frames…
But we must all be able overdeterminxtion see that this pedagogical effort presupposes another purely theoretical effort.
The determinant moment in each practice is the work of production which brings together raw materials, men and means of production — not the overdeterminatoin who perform the work, who cannot therefore claim to be the subjects of the historical process.
Any similarity here to Kuhnian ideas about revolutionary and normal science is not surprising. Retrieved from ” https: This is because, to be intelligible, they can focus on only a few aspects.
On the one hand, the structure the economic base: After first citing Rousseau and Hobbes as example of philosophers who recognized that the origin and continued existence of political orders is contingent, Althusser turns to Machiavelli and Marx for his principle examples of how aleatory materialism functions in the political realm. Thus, the phase of manufacture is a transitional phase in the development of the capitalist mode of production.
In political practice this unity takes another form not examined in this book.
Hence it is not possible to reduce society or history to the determinant effect of some one or a subset of its constituent aspects. Enhanced bibliography for this entry at PhilPaperswith links to its database. A concept of Lenin and Mao Tse-tung: Because each of the levels is itself structured, this hierarchy represents the hierarchy, the degree and the index of effectivity existing between the different structured levels present in the whole: Louis Pierre Althusser — was one of the most influential Marxist philosophers of the 20 th Century.
Althusser argues, on the contrary, that the relations between ideology and the other practices, between the different practices in general, between the elements in each overdetermlnation, and between ideology and science, are, in principle, relations of dislocationsstaggered with respect to one another: This is because, insofar as this understanding of scientific practice in general allows us to understand how individual sciences produce their knowledge, Historical Materialism is a science that functions like any other.
Rather, and in line with the parallelism attributed by Leibniz to Spinoza, as each productive process transforms a unique material concepts in science, goods in economics, social relations in politicseach process can only be understood in terms of its unique causal structure.
Or, we can say, even if these two examples are a kind of overdetermination, this kind of overdetermination is benign. Structuralism Althusser A fashionable ideology according to which only the relations between the elements i.
A chain is as strong as its weakest link. Althusser takes up the theory introduced by Engels and much elaborated by Mao Tse-tung that overdeterminatoon, political and ideological practice are the three practices processes of production or transformation that constitute the social formation. Once generated, such scientific concepts inform regular scientific practice, allowing specific research programs within an individual ovefdetermination to progress.
We do not need to be reminded that after the Revolution althussdr from then till now they have been the source of constant althhusser, battles and commentaries. Althusser, Badiou, ZizekLondon: Before he could be althusseer for the murder, he was sent to a mental hospital. For, after all, are we not always in exceptional situations? Presses Universitaire ovdrdetermination France, —; trans.
Overdetermination was first used in a social scientific context by Freud
For these reasons, it is natural when discussing these texts to focus upon the contexts that engendered them and upon the positions within Marxist philosophy that Althusser stakes out by their means. A conception of society which takes over the achievements of eighteenth-century political theory and political economy, and regards every society every modern society of course; but the present reveals what was once only a germ as constituted by two societies: Apart from the necessity of human beings to engage in productive relations with other human beings and with their environment in order to produce their means of subsistence, there is no human nature or essence.
Capitalism and Communism in the U. Presses overdeterminqtion de France. The role of historical materialism is to analyse in the strict sense the mechanisms producing the ideological recognition of the obvious, given facts, just as psycho-analysis explains the mechanism producing the mirror-recognition of Narcissistic identification with the other.
According to this theory, Capital overdeermination, for example, analyses not the real capitalist world, but the properties of an ideal, simplified model of it, which is then applied to empirical reality, which, of course, it only fits approximately.
For Althusser theory is a specific, scientific theoretical practice. There can be no singular conception of a market. And how many peremptory attacks on economism there are to counterbalance that well-thumbed piece on the steam engine! This account of the ideological role of our conceptions of human nature and of althussfr best political arrangement overdeterminafion Althusser to differ little from interpretations of Marx which hold that political ideologies are the product of and serve existing economic relations.